Introduction
Nanotechnology, often abbreviated as nanotech is referred to as imaging, designing, modeling, formulation, characterization, and application of structures by controlled modification of size and shape at the nanometer scale (1nm to 100nm), thereby, producing system with novel properties. Particles formulated in such a manner are termed as nanoparticles.1
The ethosomes are vesicular carrier systems consisting of hydroalcoholic or hydro/alcoholic/glycolic phospholipid with relatively high alcoholic concentrations (Figure 1). Main components of ethosomes are phospholipids, ethanol (upto 45%), glycerol and water, which facilitate delivery of high concentration of active ingredients through skin.2, 3
As ethosomes are soft and malleable vesicles, they serve as potential carriers for drug transportation. Active drug permeation can be enhanced by acclimatizing due to efficacy, safety, and simplicity in their medication.
Table 1 xemplifies the components of ethosome along with their examples,concentrations and uses.
Table 1
The advances within the field of nanotechnology have led to the likelihood of converting metallic silver into finer nanoparticles. These nanoparticles are more practical than the first form against microbes. These nano particles have proven to create topical silver treatment more practical and safer.5, 6, 7
Silver sulfadiazine (SSD)
Silver Sulfadiazine is a sulfonamide-based topical agent with broad spectrum antibacterial and antifungal activity. The chemical category of silver sulfadiazine is sulfonamides.
Silver sulfadiazine (SSD) is an efficient antibacterial agent approved by the USFDA, which is taken into account as the gold standard treatment in burn injuries.8, 9, 10
Mechanism of action of SSD8, 9, 10
Silver is a biocide, which binds to a broad range of targets. Silver ions bind to nucleophilic amino acids, further sulfhydryl, amino, imidazole, phosphate, and carboxyl groups in proteins, causing protein denaturation and enzyme inhibition. When SSD agent interacts with sodium chloride-containing body fluids, silver ions are released sluggishly and sustainably into wounded areas. Ionized silver atoms catalyze the formation of disulfide bonds resulting in protein structural changes and inactivating thiol-containing enzymes; silver ions may also fitDNA thereby snooping with replication and transcription of bacteria. As a competitive inhibitor of para-aminobenzoic acid (PABA), sulfadiazine inhibits bacterial dihydropteroate synthase, thereby acting in disruption of folic acid metabolism and eventually DNA synthesis.
Pathophysiology of burns
Burn is defined as an injury causing destruction to the epidermal, dermal or other deeper tissues on exposure to thermal, chemical or electrical agents. 11
A survey conducted by World Health Organization indicates that in a year approximately 1,80,000 people die due to burns. Therefore, it has been declared as a global public health problem by WHO.12, 13 According to the data of American Burn Association (ABA), there are over 4,50,000 of fatal burn injuries occurring alone in United States.14
Chemical sequences occurring at the time of burn
As a result of burns, proteins in the cells denature and coagulate. The burnt tissues stimulate the release of certain chemicals like histamine, kinin, serotonin and prostaglandin. Leukocytes and platelets adhere to the endothelium and cytotoxic T cells increase, therefore, making the tissue available as an open site for infection.11, 15
Materials and Methods
Silver sulfadiazine was a gift sample from Macsen Drugs, Gudli, Udaipur. Chemicals like soya lecithin, ethanol, ammonia solution (25%), propylene glycol and carbopol 934K were obtained from the laboratory of Bhupal Nobles College of Pharmacy, Udaipur. All chemical solvents were of analytical grade and used without further purifications.
Preformulation Studies
Melting point determination
The melting point of the sample is done to check the purity of the sample. Melting point is defined as the temperature at which a solid substance transits its state from solid to liquid.17 Melting point of silver sulfadiazine was found by using the digital melting point apparatus from Remi Instruments.
Solubility analysis
Solubility is defined as the ability of a solute to dissolve in a liquid (solvent) to form a homogeneous solution. Factors affecting solubility are; type of solvent used, temperature and pressure.18
Solubility analysis was primarily performed in order to find out a suitable solvent to dissolve the API, lipid and excipients used for formulation preparation.
Partition coefficient of the drug
Partition coefficient is the measure of the lipophilic and hydrophilic nature of a drug substance. It is defined as the extent to which a substance is distributed between two liquid phases, one being the aqueous phase and other being the oily phase. The majorly used phases are water and n-octanol (oil phase) in the ratio 1:1.19
Determination of λmax of silver sulfadiazine in 0.05% ammonia solution
Accurately weighed 100mg of silver sulfadiazine was added to a 100 ml volumetric flask. The drug was then shaken using 0.05% ammonia solution and volume was made up to the mark to get a stock solution. From this stock solution, aliquots of 100µg/ml were prepared by further dissolving 10ml of the above solution in 100ml of 0.05% of ammonia solution. The dilution was scanned from 400–200 nm with UV spectrophotometer keeping the 0.05% ammonia solution as blank. The spectrum of absorbance versus wavelength was recorded on UV-spectroscopy and analyzed for absorbance maximum and the highest absorbance was noted.20
Calibration curve of silver sulfadiazine using 0.05% ammonia solution
A 100µg/ml solution of silver sulfadiazine was prepared using 0.05% ammonia solution. This solution of 100µg/ml was used to prepare aliquots of varying concentration viz 2-18 μg/ml respectively. Absorbance of each of the solution was measured at 254nm in UV-spectrophotometer using 0.05% ammonia solution as blank and graph of concentration versus absorbance was plotted. The slope, straight line equation and correlation coefficient were obtained from the calibration curve intercept.
Preparation of silver sulfadiazine loaded ethosomal suspension
Ethosomal suspension of silver sulfadiazine was prepared based on the hot method suggested by Elka Touitou for the exploitation of ethosomal nanocarriers.
A dilution of silver sulfadiazine was prepared in 25% ammonia solution. Six different formulations i.e. F1, F2, F3, F4, F5 and F* were prepared by changing the concentration of ethanol and propylene glycol, along with the required amount of drug (500µg) by heating the preparation to 40˚C followed by mechanical stirring at 400rpm. Lecithin was suspended in required quantity of water for a few hours and was quickly stirred mechanically at 900-1100 rpm and then heated to 40˚C so that it was completely bloomed at the time of usage. Lipid phase was added dropwise to ethanol mixture with continuous and closed magnetic stirring at room temperature for 30 min at about 300 rpm to achieve uniform mixing. The formulation was finally sonicated using a probe sonicator (Frontline Sonicator) for about 5-8 min keeping in an ice bath (4˚C). A homogenous SSD ethosomal suspension was obtained.21 The nano-ethosomal formulation was stored in a covered vessel at room temperature, away from light for further experimentation.
Composition of SSD ethosomal formulations is given in Table 2 below.
Preparation of SSD Loaded Ethosomal Gel (Ethogels)
Hydrogels were prepared by dispersing 1.5% w/w of Carbopol 934 in distilled water. The Carbopol hydrogel was neutralized by addition of triethanolamine dropwise, and then the ethosomal suspension in a ratio of 1:1 (1 part of suspension: 1 part of gel) was added to it at 200 rpm for 5 min to get a homogeneous dispersion.
Evaluation of prepared SSD-loaded ethogels
Physical appearance
The prepared gel was examined for clarity, colour, homogeneity, odour, feel upon application (greasiness, grittiness) and texture.
Viscosity
The viscosity of the prepared gel was carried out using a Brookfield viscometer using T-bar spindle (spindle#4). The speed of 3 rpm was maintained for spindle rotation and the values were measured when the gel level was stabilized.
Viscosity (mPa.S) = dial reading x factor
pH:22
A solution of 1gm of gel was prepared by dissolving in 30ml distilled water. The pH of the ethosomal gel was determined by the use of a digital pH meter.
Spreadability23, 24
The parallel plate method was used to evaluate spreading behavior using an in-house spreadability testing apparatus that consisted of two smooth glass slides to hold the gel samples tied to a pre weighed volumetric flask. Excess of the gel sample was spread on the surface of the lower slide, then the upper slide was used to cover the sample and a 100 g weight was used to compress the sample between the two slides for 5min to obtain a layer of uniform thickness.
The time (in seconds) required for the upper slide to move away to the edge of the lower slide and the weight required was recorded and spreadability was calculated using to the following equation-
Where, S is the spreadability (gm.cm/sec), M is the mass placed on the pan, L is the length of the slide (cm), and T is the time (in seconds) required to move the upper slide.
Extrudability23
The extrudability is defined as the amount of formulation that can be ejected from a collapsible tube. The test was performed using a clean aluminum collapsible tube (20 g capacity) with a tip opening diameter of 1 cm. The extrudability was evaluated in by measuring the weight of gel sample ejected from the tube opening upon pressing with fingers, while holding the tube in hands.
Content uniformity and drug content
The drug content of the prepared gels were conducted by dissolving accurately weighed quantity of 1g gel in 100 ml volumetric flask and volume was made up to 100 ml with 0.05% ammonia as a solvent. The contents were magnetically stirred for 2-3 hours. The contents were filtered followed by making appropriate dilutions. The prepared dilutions were analyzed spectrophotometrically using an UV spectrophotometer at a maximum wavelength of 254nm.
In vitro drug release
The in vitro drug release studies from prepared SSD ethosomes were performed using dialysis bag diffusion technique.
0.5ml of each prepared SSD ethosomal formulation was filled into the diffusion bag and bag was precisely tied with threads at both the ends and suspended in a beaker which was filled with phosphate buffer solution (PBS) at pH 7.4. The prepared model was stirred with the help of a magnetic stirrer (Remi Equipments, India) at 50 rpm. Samples were withdrawn from the receiver medium at time intervals of 0, 0.5, 1, 1.5, 2, 2.5, 3, 3.5, 4, 4.5, 5, 5.5 hours and then were replaced with equal volumes of fresh PBS. The pH was mandatorily maintained to 7.4 every time. The amount of drug released in buffer was determined using a UV-Vis spectrophotometer at 254 nm, keeping PBS as blank.
Stability study
Ethosomal gel formulations were stored in well closed glass beakers under the following conditions and testing was performed at the specified time points:
Room temperature at 25±˚C: analysis was performed after the 14th and 28th days of storage.
Refrigerated temperature at 4±2˚C: analysis was done after the 14th and 28th days of storage.
Results and Discussion
Identification of pure drug
Melting point determination
Melting point of silver sulfadiazine was determined to be 284°C. It was observed that Silver Sulfadiazine’s melting point falls in line with USP standard therefore, it confirms that the drug is free of any impurities.
Solubility analysis
Silver sulfadiazine is insoluble in distilled water, slightly soluble in acetone, practically insoluble in alcohol, chloroform, ether and is freely soluble in 30% ammonia.
Partition coefficient
The Log P of Silver Sulfadiazine was found to be around 2.1 indicating that the drug is highly lipophilic in nature.
Particle size of pure SSD
Particle size was determined using Malvern Zetasizer and was found that all the particles have an average size range lying between 0.1 to 12 μm. The graph obtained is depicted in Figure 4.
Determination of λmax
The absorbance spectrum of pure Silver sulfadiazine was scanned using a double beam UV spectrophotometer (Shimadzu 1900) in the range 400nm-200nm with concentration of 100 μg/ml in 0.05% ammonia solution. The maximum absorption was obtained at 254 nm.
Standard calibration curve of silver sulfadiazine
The calibration curve of Silver Sulfadiazine was obtained by using the 2-18µg/ml concentration of Silver Sulfadiazine in 0.05% ammonia solution. The absorbance was measured at 254nm. The calibration curve which was plotted was linear in the range of 2-18μg/ ml at λmax 254nm. The correlation coefficient was found to be 0.996. The calibration curve is depicted in Table 3 and Figure 5.
Table 3
S. No. |
Concentration (μg/ml) |
Absorbance |
1. |
2 |
0.136 |
2. |
4 |
0.19 |
3. |
6 |
0.29 |
4. |
8 |
0.393 |
5. |
10 |
0.479 |
6. |
12 |
0.556 |
7. |
14 |
0.622 |
8. |
16 |
0.718 |
9. |
18 |
0.785 |
Table 4
Statistical Parameters |
Results |
λ max |
254nm |
Regression equation (y = mx + c) |
0.041x + 0.046 |
Slope (m) |
0.041 |
Intercept (c) |
0.046 |
Correlation coefficient (R2) |
0.996 |
Table 5
Table 6
S. No. |
Formulation Code |
Drug Content (%) |
1. |
F1 |
46.44 |
2. |
F2 |
48.24 |
3. |
F3 |
53.30 |
4. |
F4 |
81.64 |
5. |
F5 |
74.59 |
6. |
F* |
70.34 |
Table 7
Table 8
Evaluation of prepared SSD-loaded ethogels
Physical appearance, pH, viscosity, spreadability and extrudability of the prepared gel
All the prepared formulations were homogenous in appearance and smooth in texture. The pH of all was found to be in range of 6.7-7.2, which suit the skin pH indicating the skin compatibility.
Drug content
The drug content of SSD loaded topical ethogels was found to be maximum in formulation F4 i.e. 81.64%. The percentage drug content of formulations F4, F5 and F* was found to be satisfactory. Hence, the method adopted for gel formulations was found to be suitable.
The percentage drug content of SSD loaded topical ethogels is tabulated in Table 7.
In vitro drug release
Release of SSD from different ethosomal formulations was estimated by using UV spectrophotometer at 254nm using PBS at pH 7.4. The drug release at different time intervals is shown in Table 8. The study revealed that the drug release from SSD ethosomes can be ranked in following descending order F4>F5>F*. The results can be concluded that with increasing concentration of ethanol the drug release increases, which could be due to increased fluidity of the bilayer membrane.
Stability studies
The stability studies of SSD loaded topical ethogels were performed at room temperature and refrigerated temperature after two weeks and one month of storage. The results are depicted in Table 8.
Summary and Conclusion
The main objective of the study was to develop and characterize a “Silver Sulfadiazine Loaded Ethosomal Gel for Treatment of Topical Burns”.
In the present work, ethosomal suspensions of silver sulfadiazine were formulated by using varied concentrations of ethanol, lecithin, and propylene glycol. Theses SSD suspensions were further loaded into the hydrogel made up of Carbopol 934 in the ration of 1:1. SSD entrapped in ethosomal vesicles enhances their skin permeability and allows the drug to be delivered to the targeted site in a controlled release fashion.
The % drug content and the in vitro drug release studies revealed that formulation F4 showed the maximum amount of drug release within five hours. Hence, from all the preparations prepared, F4 was chosen to be the best one.
According to the findings, it can be concluded that that SSD ethogels can prove to be an effective and more efficient system for burn treatments than compared to the traditional SSD creams and ointments that are commercially available.
Acknowledgement
The authors would like to sincerely thank Macsen Drugs, Gudli, Udaipur for providing Silver sulfadiazine API as a gift sample. We owe gratitude to Dr. Anshu Sharma, BN College of Pharmacy, Udaipur and Dr. Manish Kumar Aggrawal (Madhav University, Abu Road) for their valuable support.